Is abortion murder?

There’s a reason that question never goes away – there’s no right or wrong answer to it. Ask a group of people if a zygote qualifies as a person and most of them would probably say no – it’s a POTENTIAL person, not an actual person. Ask that same group of people, however, if a 9-month-old fetus is a person, and a lot more would probably say yes.

What do we learn from that? There’s an awful lot of people out there who think that when the baby is growing inside its mother, there’s a certain threshold it crosses where it graduates from being merely a potential person to being an actual person. But you put yourself on a slippery slope if you say something like that. What you’re implying is that there’s a certain specific, clearly defined point in time that makes all the difference. One day an abortion would be okay, and the very next it’s murder. Who’s to say when exactly that is?

There’s another group of people who like to straddle the fence by saying something to the variety of, “Abortion is murder, but a girl should be able to get an abortion if she was raped.” WTF?! If abortion is murder, but the girl was impregnated by being raped, does that stop it from being murder? Make up your fucking mind!

There’s no clear-cut right or wrong answer to this. So what should we do?

Pro-life people would tell you that we should err on the side of life and outlaw abortion. But how much sense does that make? What they’re saying is this:

“Since there’s no right or wrong answer, we should take the decision out of the hands of the individual and have the state declare that no-one can do this.”

The pro-choice camp, on the other hand, says simply this:

“Decide for yourself.”

On no level – federal, state, or local – should the government have the authority to tell you that you can’t get an abortion. If you believe that abortion is murder – fine. Don’t get one. But don’t try to force your decision on everybody else, and if you’re using religion to justify your argument … well … I’ll listen to you as soon as you enter the age of reason.

Please think twice before giving the government any more power and influence over our lives. Once we lose a little bit of our liberty, it’s really hard to get it back. Government positions, by nature, attract the type of people who like to control the lives of others, and if history is any indication, they do a really shitty job of it. Government screws things up.

Err on the side of freedom.

By: Nick Ahrens

Posted by Nick A., filed under Thoughts. Date: January 8, 2008, 10:04 pm | 20 Comments »

  • Brian Sitz


  • http://www.myspace.com/jessicrap Jessica


  • Z

    I have some problems with your argument.

    First two paragraphs, not bad. Do remember that the difference of one day, in a legal context, means a lot and is pretty routine (think: driving a car, getting married, consent, drinking).

    Par. 3. Those who refer to abortion as murder but think it’s acceptable in the case of rape/danger to mother think that way because it is extenuating circumstance, and is therefore NOT murder. If you shoot a guy in the head, it’s homicide. If you shoot a guy in the head because he was trying to shoot you, it’s self defense. There is a moral/ethical/legal difference, even if the outcome is the same.
    Your “quote” (par. 6) of pro-lifer’s point of view is a poor representation. They don’t say “there is no right or wrong answer”. They clearly state that there IS a right answer or wrong answer, ie abortion is wrong. They say based on their own moral/ethical values, some of which is derived from religion.

    Before you cry out that the government shouldn’t enforce morality, remember my example above. When the government says that you can’t murder someone, or makes the distinction between homicide and self-defense, they ARE enforcing morality, not just what is consensual.

    As for his last 2 paragraphs, seems pretty accurate.

    BTW I am completely pro-choice. I just think your argument is kinda weak.

  • Nick A.

    Z, I see where you’re coming from.

    Regarding your comments about paragraph 3, although I know it’s not YOUR viewpoint, I think you’d agree that the argument you described there is pretty subjective itself. Lots of people would probably say the comparison between shooting an aggressor and aborting because of rape doesn’t hold because the aggressor is guilty of something and the unborn child isn’t, etc, etc, etc.

    I understand what you say about my quote in paragraph 6, but I based that quote off the assumption that I’d been able to convince the reader that there is no completely right or wrong answer, hehe. I know it’s wishful thinking to believe that I was able to convince everyone who reads it, but I seriously don’t believe there is any clearly-defined right or wrong answer, which is why I believe the best we can do is leave it to individual choice.

    And I’m not saying that the government shouldn’t enforce morality at all; I applaud the fact that they outlaw murder and make a distinction between homicide and self defense and all that, but in the case of abortion, I don’t think the morality is nearly as well-defined. The idea that we should put women who have abortions into the same category as people like Ted Bundy and the Son of Sam just doesn’t make sense to me.

    Still, I see where you’re coming from.

  • Joe


  • Zero

    Joe: The bible says nothing about abortion. The technology to do so did not exist at the time. You are a moron.

    Read this: http://www.ffrf.org/nontracts/abortion.php

    Everyone else: Quite frankly, no person should be forced to hold any opinion, period. If you think that killing an aggressor is wrong, so be it. However, I should be allowed to defend myself, no? If you think that abortions are amoral, fine, and you have every right to say so. However, you do not have the right to force your opinion on anyone else.

  • http://www.iansouter.com Ian

    Hey Joe, spellcheck much?

  • http://fallofhate.blogspot.com BJNebraska

    “if you’re using religion to justify your argument … well … I’ll listen to you as soon as you enter the age of reason.”

    I love it! :)

  • Patrick

    Like the above poster said, the first two paragraphs are pretty spot on. In your third, you mentioned rape. Personally, I don’t agree that people who get raped should be allowed to abort their babies. While I’m sure many people say this to appear moderate, it doesn’t make much sense. I am completely against abortion unless the mothers life is at risk in deciding to keep it. I also believe that a person is alive as soon as it becomes a fetus. Very early on.

    I believe that there is a right answer, and that answer is that abortion is killing. Just like a Pro-lifer would say that their answer is the right one.

    I believe that abortion is a state issue. Why a state issue? Because I believe abortion is murder, and states deal with murders, something the federal government should stay out of. I support the government defining life at conception, how a state chooses to punish anyone who has an abortion is up to them. If the state wants to make it illegal and fined, sure. If a state wants it to be a crime, but have no penalty, fine. If a state wants it to be completely legal, then it is again their choice.

    I’d also like to point out that I don’t believe it’s murder for religious reasons. I am not religious at all. I just truly believe it’s killing. Murder? Not sure. But killing, definitely.

    The problem with the whole issue is on both sides. The pro life side uses religion to justify their opinion. This is the wrong way to approach the issue, because the pro choice side just uses their religious justifications against them by saying the church should stay out of government issues.

    It’s not a religious issue though. It’s an issue between life and death, and we need to come together and decide if a fetus really is life. If you believe it is life like I do, then you should probably be disgusted that they are being killed. If you don’t believe it’s alive, then I can understand your point of view.

    Also, I didn’t want this to come across as an attack or anything.

  • Patrick

    Also, in my third paragraph, first line, I meant to say “killing”, not “murder”.

  • Margaret

    You really need to learn more about Abortion before you write an piece like this. Your “pro-life” arguments are woefully incorrect. It is obvious you have never talked to a pro-life person and you get your facts from what the pro-choice people say the pro-lifers say. It is really ignorant to put forth someone else’s view and not even have it right.

  • Nick A.

    OK, Margaret, what am I missing?

  • http://www.iansouter.com Ian

    I’ve noticed that most of the pro-life people are the same people that fall in behind our president when he sends a bunch of our citizens off to die for a bunch of lies. George Carlin said it best, “We need lots of live babies so they can grow up to be dead soldiers.”

  • Patrick

    ^And what’s that have to do with anything?

    (also, I would like to add that I don’t like the current president at all. Just thought I’d put that out there…)

  • Z

    Yes, my example is rather subjective, as evidenced by Patrick’s opinion. However, I wasn’t necessarily saying that aborting and homicide are the same thing. I was just giving an example of another topic in which moral/ethical/legal distinctions are made.

    Oh, and thanks for actually replying and not fire bombing me.

    @BJNebraska and Nick
    OK, religion blows, I get it. But never put it too far out of your head that Reason, without regard to human values and emotion, is brutal. Humans aren’t robots. We make irrational choices. Of course, this is just my philosophical POV.

    I’m on the fence about state power. At heart I think that the people should have their right to make choices I don’t agree with, but I sorta just want to “err of the side of liberty.” An article I think you might like: http://www.reason.com/news/show/120792.html

    Sloppily touching base and i’m out.

    And remember kids, don’t feed the trolls

  • John

    I’m pretty pro-choice, but I think your logic is wrong here. If abortion is the killing of an innocent being, as pro-lifers believe, it’s not appropriate to let individuals decide for themselves. Look at how our entire justice system is based on the presumption of innocence. We err on the side of protecting innocent life, as I think we should. That’s why executions cost more than life imprisonments–the cost of erasing any shred of reasonable doubt that a convicted killer is innocent is astronomical (though of course we aren’t always correct even after the appeal process finishes). If one believes that there’s any chance that a fetus is actually a child, it’s a perfectly reasonable response to say that the state should step in and protect that possible innocent life.

    I’ll put this another way. Before slavery was abolished in the US, some people looked at slaves as property, while others looked at them as people. Abolitionists wanted the state to step in and prevent the immoral imprisonment of people, even though slaveowners disagreed with the underlying premise that slaves were not property, but human beings. Was this inappropriate? According to your logic, abolitionists should have stepped back and said:

    “Well, there is widespread disagreement over whether slaves are people or property. So instead of having the state to step in, we should allow individuals to decide which category slaves fall into. If you think slaves are people, fine–don’t buy one. But if you think they’re property, enslave away.”

    Would that have been acceptable? I don’t think so. What they actually argued was:

    “Though there is widespread disagreement about whether slaves are people or property, those who believe that they’re property are incorrect. To allow those who falsely believe that slaves aren’t people to imprison others is immoral. The state must step in, declare that slaves are people, and stop this injustice.”

    Of course, the parallels aren’t perfect, and I’m not necessarily saying that the pro-life argument is correct. I’m just saying that, if someone has the belief that abortion is the killing of an innocent being, it’s perfectly logical to seek to make abortion illegal.

  • Nick A.

    (In response to John’s comments)

    We indeed have a justice system that errs on the side of protecting innocent life, but that by itself doesn’t prove that it’s morally justified to apply that type of logic to abortions.

    And as far as your slavery example is concerned, I’ll agree with you on one thing: the parallels definitely aren’t perfect. In the slavery case, the morality is much more well-defined, and more people back then should have seen it that way. From your comments, I think you’d agree with me on that.

    But for the reasons I outlined in the essay, the morality of abortions is NOT so well-defined, especially considering the fact that it’s the woman who bears the burden of carrying the baby inside her own body for 9 months.

    Leaving it to individual choice is the most morally-justified and “common sense” solution. An individual knows more about her own life than society as a whole ever can. Let her use the sources of wisdom that are closest to her own life to make a decision, and if she decides to get an abortion, let her deal with the feelings that come with it as she may.

    I’m curious, though (since my take on the issue didn’t impress you), what is YOUR justification for being pro-choice?

    (And mind you, I don’t mean that in a smart-alec kind of way; I’m honestly curious.)

  • John

    (In response to Nick)

    I agree that the morality is much more well-defined for slavery, but that’s only apparent in retrospect. No matter how easy it is to look back and criticize people for being so blind as to think that slaves weren’t people too, we have to remember that what’s obvious now wasn’t obvious then. So while from my perspective, an embryo is not a human life on par with an infant, I have to accept that that belief is in large part a product of the culture and time in which I live. It’s possible that in the future people will look back and be appalled at that belief.

    I agree that women know more about their lives than society can, but with that said, if a pro-life person believes that an embryo is a child, leaving abortion to individual choice is just not a viable option. If someone wants to carry out an act you believe is the murder of an innocent, you will seek to stop them, regardless of how justified they think they are. Letting them come to their own decisions and “deal with the feelings that come with it” wouldn’t be acceptable to someone who believes that a murder is occurring.

    (I do completely agree, however, that it’s silly for pro-lifers to say that abortion is murder, but okay in the case of rape, incest, or when the life of the mother is threatened.)

    With that said, I’m pro-choice. This is mostly because, on the whole, restrictive abortion laws don’t decrease the incidence of abortion. (http://economist.com/world/international/displaystory.cfm?story_id=9989951) So there’s really not much justification for making abortion illegal if all we’ll be doing is endangering the lives of mothers. I am personally opposed to abortion, because I feel that since no one really knows when a fetus becomes a human life worthy of society’s protection, we should try to err on the side of protecting what may be a human life. But since laws are fairly ineffective in this situation, it makes more sense to allow individuals to seek abortion if they choose while trying to discourage abortions on a cultural level.

    I do think that Roe v. Wade was a blatant overstretch of judicial authority and should be reversed, but that’s because of the case itself, not my feelings on abortion. And were Roe v. Wade to be overturned, I’d oppose abortion bans locally.

  • Patrick

    @Nick: For people who are pro-choice, no it isn’t an easily definable line between what’s right and what’s wrong. I can understand if you thought that. But for someone who is pro-life, then it’s very well defined. Just as defined as slavery was to people who were abolitionists.

  • http://doodeesthailand.blogspot.com/ Doodee

    Thanks for sharing

  • what is klonopin Online Without Prescription Best Prices. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest vigrx penis enlargement pills Now Guaranteed Shipping. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheapest most effective diet pill Now Top Online Pharmacy Supplier. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheap cialis delivery Now Pharmacy At The Best Price! Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap buy vitamin supplement online Online Cheap Pharmacy Online. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest propecia india Online WorldWide Shipping. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest strongest prescription pain killer Now Pharmacy At The Best Price! Best Online.
  • Buy drugstore online Without Prescription Doctor. Low Prices. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheap muscle relaxants over the counter Online Best Online. The Largest Internet Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap fat burning herbs Now Internet Prices For fat burning herbs! Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheap generic viagra lowest prices Online WorldWide Shipping. 24/Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap online drug stores Online Pharmacy Store. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheapest viagra vs levitra Now Best Internet. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest taking viagra after cialis Now Low Prices. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheapest non prescription pain relievers Now Buy Medications Online. Best Internet.
  • Buying Cheap pharmacokinetics of diazepam. Mexican Pharmacy, Good Prices. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap remedy for toothache pain Now Special Prices For remedy for toothache pain! Best Online.
  • Buy Cheap zoloft 25mg Now No Prescription Needed. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap strongest otc pain reliever available Online Best Drugstore. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest levitra in canada Now Guaranteed Shipping. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheapest anxiety drugs Now 24/Online Pharmacy. Top Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap clomid progesterone Online Cheap Prescription Drugs. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheap drugs for arthritis Now Free Viagra Pills! 24/Online Pharmacy.
  • overdose on ativan Online Without Prescription Free Viagra Pills! Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap buy tramadol online no prescription Online Best Drugstore. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheap cialis with no prescription Online Best Prices. Top Online Pharmacy Supplier.
  • phentermine diet pill Online Without Prescription Low Prices. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheapest xanax online ordering Now Best Drugstore. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest free xanax online Now Pharmacy At The Best Price! Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheap where can i buy viagra online Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheap amoxicillin dosage Online Online Medical Shop. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheapest phentermine no prescription Now No Prescription Needed. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest cheapest cialis erectile dysfunction pill Now Pharmacy Store. Cheap Prescription Drugs.
  • prevention of obesity Online Without Prescription Best Prices. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap usa online pharmacy Online Low Prices. Internet Prices For usa online pharmacy!
  • Buy Cheapest clonazepam drug Now Buy Medications Online. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap weight loss doctors Online Best Online. Top Online Pharmacy Supplier.
  • Buy Cheap medicine purchasing Online Low Prices. Special Prices For medicine purchasing!
  • description codeine sulfate Online Without Prescription Free Viagra Pills! Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest buy pheromone to attract woman Online Cheap Pharmacy Online. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest india online pharmacy Online Best Prices. Cheap Prescription Drugs.
  • Buy Cheapest buy ativan no prescription Online Buy Drugs Online No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy Cheap fastin diet pills Online Cheap Pharmacy Online. Top Online Pharmacy.
  • levitra use instructions Online Without Prescription Pharmacy Store. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest phentermine online Now 24/Online Pharmacy. Best Drugstore.
  • how to treat muscle spasms Online Without Prescription Low Prices. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest buy ativan no prescription Online Best Internet. No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy Cheap canadian drugstores online Now WorldWide Shipping. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheapest cialis delivery Now Best Drugstore. Discount Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest valtrex coupon Online Best Drugstore. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheapest cheapest viagra online Now No Prescription Needed. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest cialis pill online Now Guaranteed Shipping. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest buy tadalafil cialis Online Low Prices. Cheap Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheapest muscle spasm medication Online Free Viagra Pills! 24/Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest diet pill for fast weight loss Online Best Drugstore. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest buy codeine online Online Best Prices. Discount Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheap diflucan dosage Online Special Prices For diflucan dosage! Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap cheap antidepressant pills Now Order Cheap Meds Without Rx. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap how to curb your appetite Now Top Online Pharmacy Supplier. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest pain medication for sale Now Best Drugstore. Discount Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheap viagra in china Online Online Medical Shop. Top Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap viagra pills cod Now 24/Online Pharmacy. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap online pain medication no prescription Now Guaranteed Shipping. Cheap Prescription Drugs.
  • Buy Cheap buy discount cialis Now Buy Medications Online. Free Viagra Pills!
  • generic for viagra Online Without Prescription Top Online Pharmacy. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest spinal osteoarthritis arthritis buy medication Now Top Online Pharmacy. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap cialis order online Online 24/Online Pharmacy. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap online mexico pharmacy Online Buy Medications Online. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest natural pain reliever Now Cheap Prescription Drugs. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheap clomid and multiple births Now Drugs, Health And Beauty. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest side effects bactrim Now Pharmacy Store. Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheapest valium half life Now Prescription Drugs And Generic Medications.
  • Buy Cheapest buy clomid where Online Get FDA Approved Prescription Medicines.
  • Buy Cheapest new arthritis drugs Now Free Viagra Pills! Guaranteed Shipping.
  • fat burner weight loss products Online Without Prescription Online Medical Shop. Low Prices.
  • Buying Cheap buing cialis. Offshore Rx, Good Prices. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest low cost phentermine no prescription Online Low Prices. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheap india online drugstores Online Order Cheap Meds Without Rx. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheap pfizer viagra otc Online Online Prices For pfizer viagra otc! Best Online.
  • Buy Cheap order pain meds by phone Now Special Prices For order pain meds by phone! Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap how are drugs delivered to pharmacies Online WorldWide Shipping. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap vitamin shops Now Low Prices. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
  • Buy Cheap ambien buy generic Now 24/Internet)(safe Pharmacy. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheapest sildenafil citrate side effects Online Online Medical Shop. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap buy generic acomplia Online 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest diet pills in canada Online No Prescription Needed. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest where can i buy phentermine online Online No Prescription Needed. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest cheap phentermine without prescription Now Order Cheap Meds Without Rx. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest blue pills Online Online Medical Shop. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheap discounted viagra Now All Medications Are Certificated! Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest strongest pain medications Online Pharmacy Store. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap cialis indian pharmacy Now Order Cheap Meds Without Rx. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap cialis pharmacy Now WorldWide Shipping. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheap health product woman Now Top Online Pharmacy. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheap cheap xanax without prescription Now Best Internet. Top Online Pharmacy Supplier.
  • Buy Cheap the drug ambien Now Best Online. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
  • Buy Cheap variety sample levitra Online Best Prices. No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy Cheap cheap bactrim Now Discount Pharmacy Online. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap does levitra work Now Special Prices For does levitra work! Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap canadian online internet pharmacy Now Cheap Pharmacy Online. No Prescription Needed.